Direct Property vs Aussie Shares. The winner is…Direct Propertyright-arrow
read-time6 mins
by Charter Hall Announcements

To access this part of the website, please select your country of residence from the following list.

The country of my primary residence is:

Due to legal restrictions, access to this website is only available to residents of Australia and New Zealand from within Australia or New Zealand. In order to access this website, you must provide the State, Territory or Province and postcode for your primary residential address within Australia or New Zealand.

The State or Territory of my primary residence in Australia or the Province of my primary residence in New Zealand is:

Due to legal restrictions, access to this website is only available to residents of Australia and New Zealand from within Australia or New Zealand. In order to access this website, you must provide the State, Territory or Province and postcode for your primary residential address within Australia or New Zealand.

The State or Territory of my primary residence in Australia or the Province of my primary residence in New Zealand is:

By proceeding you confirm that you are a resident of Australia or New Zealand accessing this website from within Australia or New Zealand and you represent, warrant and agree that:

  • you are not in the United States or a “U.S. person”, as defined in Regulation S under the U.S. Securities Act of 1933, as amended (“U.S. Person”), nor are you acting for the account or benefit of a U.S. Person;
  • you will not make a copy of the documents on this website available to, or distribute a copy of such documents to, or for the account or benefit of, any U.S. Person or any person in any other place in which, or to any other person to whom, it would be unlawful to do so; and
  • the state, territory or province and postcode provided by you below for your primary residence in Australia or New Zealand are true and accurate.

I agree to the above terms Yes or No.

Unfortunately, legal restrictions prevent us from allowing you access to this website. If you have any questions, please contact us by e-mail by clicking on the link below.

Contact Us

By Steven Bennett, Head of Charter Hall Direct

 

Its widely agreed the foundation of any retirement savings strategy for the majority of investors is balance or diversification.

Nonetheless ‘Overweight cash and Aussie equities’ is one of the most common observations I hear from fund managers, brokers, accountants, advisers and consultants when talk turns to nest egg construction or asset allocation of the typical Australian self-directed investor or SMSF trustee or member.

The reasons for this tendency are not hard to fathom.

Cash, although very low yielding in the current environment, is safe; and Aussie equities are accessible, known, highly visible and well understood.

What’s not widely-realised is the strong performance of a particular class of property investment, namely ‘direct property’ (also known as ‘unlisted property trusts’).

Direct property, or unlisted property funds, are a means for investors to own units in large, high quality Australian commercial properties that would normally be out of reach for the average person to wholly own in their own name.

Examples of the most common types of commercial property include CBD office buildings, large commercial warehouses and logistics facilities and retail centres.

In short, direct property provides access to high quality investment grade assets – the same class of assets owned by the big institutional and wholesale investors.

The other common way investors can own units in a major property, or a suite of major properties, is through ASX listed property trusts usually referred to by the short hand A-REITs (Australian Real Estate Investment Trusts).

The two big differences between A-REITs and Direct property funds is the valuation methods for units and liquidity. The price of an A-REIT is listed on the ASX and on any day the price may be above or below the underlying value of the assets in the trust, depending on market sentiment. A-REITS are also highly liquid, being ASX listed.

Units in Direct Property funds directly reflect the actual valuation of the building or buildings in the fund and direct property units should be regarded as illiquid. A fund has a defined term and the units can be cashed in at the end of the term, although there are sometimes limited liquidity events during the term.

When it comes to performance, many people in the investment scene are surprised to learn how well direct property can perform and even more so when it is highlighted that the asset class has performed better that Australia equities over the last 5 year and 10-year periods.

The first chart below gives a performance comparison of direct property vs A-REITS and Australian equities.  For the year to June 2018, Australian unlisted property funds posted a total return (distributions and capital growth) of +18.7%; A-REITs +9.7%; and Australian equities +12.9%. The performance of direct property over 3 and 5 years is also more than double that of Aussie equities! It should be noted that past performance is not a reliable indication of future performance and that different asset classes have different liquidity and risk profiles.

 

 

Past performance is not an indicator of future performance. Different asset classes have different liquidity and risk profiles.

Source: Property Funds Association Fact Sheet – June 2018

The second chart shows a longer history of performance of direct property and details the two return measures, being income distributions and capital growth. The latter, while plotted or recorded regularly via the unit price valuation is generally only realised at the end of the term of the investment. You can see the income return being the light orange lines and how regular and stable the income paid to investors has been over a very long-time frame dating back to June 1986.

 

 

Past performance is not an indicator of future performance. Different asset classes have different liquidity and risk profiles.

Source: Property Funds Association Fact Sheet – June 2018

These figures make a compelling argument not only for investing in direct property but also for diversification, which is how we began this article. There’s a place for cash/fixed interest, Australian equities and property of various types… including direct property.

Charter Hall currently has four major direct or unlisted property funds open to investors, with distributions currently projected at: 5.8% p.a.1 (Direct Office Fund), 6.2%p.a.(Direct Industrial Fund No.4), 6.7% p.a.3 (Direct Diversified Consumer Staples Fund), and 6.9% p.a.4 (Direct PFA Fund). All fours funds are projected to experience significant capital growth as well, making total expected returns of between 9% and 10% p.a. over the term of each of the funds. It should be noted that Direct property funds are illiquid by their nature.

 

 

 

 

 

 

1 DOF’s yield based on the expected distribution for DOF of 8.25 cpu (annualised) for the quarter commencing 1 July 2018, and a unit price of $1.41 as at 1 July 2018. The expected distribution reflects an increase to the 8.0 cpu (annualised) distribution paid in the previous quarter.

2 DIF4’s yield based on actual distribution of 6.50 cents per unit (annualised) for the June 2018 quarter and $1.05 unit price at 1 July 2018.

3 DCSF’s yield based on actual distribution of 6.75 cents per unit (annualised) for the June 2018 quarter and $1.01 unit price at 1 July 2018.

4 PFA’s yield based on actual distribution of 7.25 cents per unit (annualised) for the June 2018 quarter and $1.05 unit price at 1 July 2018.